Cruelty

I fear my last post on The Left Hand Path was not as clear as I had intended. Perhaps it was too simple. Perhaps it went off in too many directions. Perhaps the theme is too much for one post. Clearly it left some questions open and possibly created more confusion than clarity. I apologize. I have off days!

One theme that caused some questions was the subject of cruelty. For the sake of clarification I would like to address that topic as succinctly as possible. In my opinion, neither Satanism nor any other Left Hand Path condone cruelty. To me cruelty is self evidently bad and wrong in all it’s forms.

Satanism has no universal creed or dogma. Satanism requires us each to be responsible for our selves and our own moral judgments. However many Satanists are at least informed by the Statements, Sins and Rules written down by Anton LaVey; details of which can be found at the top of this page. Within those statements there are two which could be said to refer directly to cruelty. The 7th Satanic Statement states;- Satan represents man as just another animal, sometimes better, more often worse than those that walk on all fours, who, because of his “divine spiritual and intellectual development” has become the most vicious animal of all!    I take this to mean that human beings have within them an ability to be cruel, more so than any other animal, and that this is a tendency to  be aware of and guard against. It is telling us to be aware of what we are capable of ( a glance at the news headlines any day of the week will confirm the cruelty we regularly inflict on each other) in order to avoid such behaviors.

But then number 4 of the Eleven Satanic Rules states;-  If a guest in your lair annoys you, treat him cruelly and without mercy. I think this one has to be seen in context, but even then I personally have difficulty with it. I would take this to mean that if somebody in my circle takes advantage of me they are no longer subject to the same respect or consideration I would give others. If they hurt me, I can hurt them. Perhaps without mercy; but that would be my choice, not my obligation.

Other rules in LaVeyan Satanism specifically set out to protect children and animals. So no Satanist should ever  be cruel to children or animals in any way at all. The occasional stories of  so called Satanic abuse that surface in the news are committed by ignorant thugs whose connection to Satanism is as tenuous as so called Muslims who advocate flying planes into buildings or so called Christians who bomb family planning clinics.

I’d like to say I never could or never would be cruel; but that would be a lie. Sometimes I have heard of cases of child abuse and have found myself dreaming up all kinds of horrific tortures for the perpetrators of such acts. If somebody hurt or killed somebody I loved I know I could be very cruel indeed to them if I caught them. And there are less extreme cases where I could imagine being cruel in revenge. Yet I also recognize that in all of these cases while being cruel to the perpetrator of a crime might be emotionally satisfying in revenge, it might not be the most effective way to deal with the situation and move on with my life.

Thus I accept that I can or could be cruel in some circumstances but I have no desire or inclination to be so.

Satanism doe s not advocate or condone cruelty except in extreme circumstances, and even then the responsibility lies with the individual to judge what is appropriate. (The implication being that if the individual makes the wrong choice they must accept the consequences of their actions).

However Satanism does require us to be very honest about our own nature and capabilities in order that we can progress and become better people (perhaps by balancing our base emotions with logical reason).

Personally I detest all forms of cruelty, especially those directed against children and animals. I find such things vile and dehumanizing. And I think the perpetrators of such crimes should never be released from jail. But… Is that cruel?

Advertisements

5 Comments on “Cruelty”

  1. ladyimbrium says:

    I am human, therefore I am capable of cruelty. I have always thought the connection to be obvious. I’ve also always thought that we had a responsibility to ourselves and each other to not sink so low as to be cruel without cause. I am a devotee of Ares and Aphrodite both, and they are both capable of extraordinary cruelty- but never without cause. Maybe that’s the difference? Those who hurt merely to see others hurting are worse than animals who only hurt others at need. I could, of course, be interpreting your words incorrectly. I’m still sorting a lot of these things out for myself, and you have a knack for helping me get to the core of the issue, or at least to my own core of the issue.

  2. tfaswift says:

    Hello Cassie and thank you so much for writing a follow up to the last post (which although somewhat shocking, was also witty and humorous, in your usual style). I was wondering if your definition of cruelty (as it applies to you personally) might be something along the lines of vengeance or using violence in the protection of a loved one. I think most people cannot really know what they would do under those circumstances, and I truly pity the people who have had to find out.

    I myself would have to exercise enormous self-restraint not to inflict suffering on someone who had intentionally abused, injured, tortured, violated or killed anyone that I care about. Is it wrong that I may not feel the same drive to punish them myself if they did the same things to somebody who I don’t know? Obviously I would do everything I could to bring them to justice, but that animal instinct that we all have within us to attack anyone who hurts our loved ones probably wouldn’t be there.

    That in itself is another point. Should I feel equally fierce and protective towards everyone, even if they are a stranger to me? Or should I feel forgiveness and merciful towards all people no matter what they have done? To be honest, the last option is an impossibility for me. I know there are some saintly nuns out there who can do it, but I have zero tolerance for abuse. Some things are unforgivable – to me at least.

    So I think a lot of people would feel the same way that you do. If you hurt the people (or animals) that I care about, you’d better hope I don’t find you. I know a woman who is going through that EXACT same thing right now. It’s a scary and dangerous situation. If you follow it through, well, the law in many countries does not allow for vigilantism. So I just hope I never have to face that “test” and if I do, and I catch the person who did something, I hope I can exercise the self-restraint required to just call the police and let the justice system deal with them. If that fails, (as it sometimes does), I shall leave it to karma. Karma can be brutal, and I don’t need to get my hands dirty.

    Very interesting post! Thank you.

    • Cassie says:

      Since comments on your blog seem to be closed I would just like to say thank you for the mention you gave me and the award nomination. I’m on the road again at the moment so I don’t know when I will be able to respond fully, but I will try and get to it soon. Regarding what you have said above I agree with you all the way. I think it is very important that the law’s notion of justice should reflect the wants and needs of the victim. Would say more but I have to run! 🙂

      • tfaswift says:

        Hi Cassie, safe traveling! Yes, I have comments closed for almost everything except my Blog Challenge just because I was getting a lot of comments before and didn’t have time to reply to everyone. It’s more manageable for me this way. Take care! 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s